The 2-to-1 Nap Transition

So here we are – still talking about nap transitions.

This transition is even more favoriter (poetic license 😉 ) than going from 3 naps to 2. Imagine! You end up with a WHOLE morning to go OUT and DO things! And then a whole afternoon, too!

One-nap days are my favorite kind of nap days – and they hang around for the longest, too.

But, alas, the transition to a 1-nap day is not quite so smooth or seamless as the transition to a 2-nap day.

In fact, this nap transition may just be the messiest of the lot, and sometimes (especially when working with a client who’s on the brink of a transition) I just want to close my eyes and wish it away so it won’t happen.

But, like it or not, happen it most certainly will.

So let’s talk some details then, shall we?

When?

For most kids, this transition happens around 14 months.

Girls tend to go a little earlier than boys, so they are usually ready closer to 12.5 months.

That being said – these are averages. I’ve seen this transition happen as early as 10 months and as late as 18 months.

If you have the choice, I always err to the side of having a 2-nap day – making the transition down to one nap will inevitably mean pushing your little not-quite-toddler a wee bit past their comfort zone… which is going to mean some kvetching, some overtiredness, perhaps some early morning wakes… you know: all those lovely things you DON’T want to happen.

So: as long as you can keep your kid on a two nap day – by hook or by crook – keep them there. (Even if that means waking your child early from one – or both! – nap(s).)

When do you not have a choice, though?

You don’t have a choice when your child simply refuses to take a second nap. Even if you cap that first nap at the 1-hour mark. Even if you try putting him in as absolutely close as you can to bedtime without risking bedtime becoming an utter failure. Even when you do all the troubleshooting and modifying and perfecting in the world, what ends up happening is one of three things.

1. Your baby sings, dances and throws parties in his crib until it’s too late for him to nap before bedtime (with a 7:00 bedtime, that will usually be by around 4ish)

2. Your baby yells and cries and in general sounds like a nebach case until it’s too late for him to nap before bedtime.

3. Your baby does option 1 or 2 for a while… and then falls asleep rrriiiiiiight before they need to wake up to have enough time awake before bedtime.

If either of those are happening most of the time for two weeks (yes, my dear: two whole weeks!), then you’ll know.

It’s time.

What?

So what does an approximate ideal 1 nap day look like? (Quick note here — if you’re wondering about an approximate ideal 2-nap day, check out this post.)

Well, like all things — it depends.

Mostly: how old is your child? And, of course, how long is her nap?

A younger kiddo means an earlier (and hopefully longer!) nap; an older one will be able to handle something a little later.

If your child is 10-12 months when making the transition, I’d aim for an 11:30 nap – that way, even if it’s just 2 hours, it’ll still break the day pretty evenly in half.

If she’s older – say closer to that 14 month average – she should be able to do a 12:00 nap; if she’s closer to the 18-month mark, I’d aim for 12 or even 12:30.

Regardless of the age, you want to break the day in half so that they’re not being stretched past their awake time limit too too long.

How?

So how do you make the transition?

Unlike with the 3-to-2 transition, most kids don’t transition into a 1-nap day organically. (Of course, I can tell you all about a little rule-breaker named Sir G who did… but that’s for another time.)

For nearly every single kid on the planet, you have to push it.

Literally.

Push the first nap later and later — about 30 minutes every 3 days does the trick – and the second nap will slowly fade into oblivion.

During the first couple of days, you can still put your little protester into the crib as usual, but once there’s just a narrow window of time for “sleeping” to happen, I like using motion naps to help tide transitioning babies over till bedtime.

So if, for example, your baby is napping at 10 and you’re pushing him to an 11:30 nap, once those two weeks of ‘wait and see’ are over, you’ll start with a 10:30 nap.

And hold.

Days 1, 2 and 3, nap #1 will be at 10:30, and you’ll still aim for some kind of down time/nap for nap #2 at 3ish. If she doesn’t sleep, do an early bedtime.

Day 4, the nap will move to 11:00. You may have to do something at 10 – your baby’s old nap time – to help her get over the hump to make it till 11. A fruit as snack or going outside are some great options for that. At this point, you may want to aim for a motion nap around 3:30.

As with days 1-3, if she doesn’t sleep for that second “nap”, it’s always helpful to give an early bedtime.

By day 7, you’ll have moved nap to 11:30, where you’ll be keeping it for now. Continue to offer an early bedtime as needed, and remember: transitions can be messy.

Things can take 2-6 weeks to sort out, so if you’re finding that your baby is kvetchier in general, having early wakes, crying more before bed or nap, etc. — that’s all normal. Stay on course, weather the storm and remember: this too shall pass.

So tell me: how did your wee one’s nap transition go?

Leave Comment



clear formSubmit

Comments (6)
  1. Libby Kasten

    Hey,
    Not sure how you knew im exactly at the point where my little boy (14 months) is having a heyday instead of a nap at 3.
    I cant wait to implement the above and get my peace of mind back…
    Appreciated!!
    Libby

    • Haha! You’re not the only one, Libby!
      Glad that you’re going to get your peace of mind back – and enjoy your little boy in the afternoon instead of dreading his heyday.

      Hatzlacha,
      Chaya Shifra

  2. kaila grunwald

    My darling is almost 17 months old and has been doing a 1 nap a day for 2-3 weeks. I find that she is really tired with this schedule. However, with 2 naps she ends up with a late bedtime and shorter night. Any ideas?

    • Hi Kaila,

      My advice: hang in there! The nap transition can take up to a full 6 weeks before the dust settles and things even out, so still seeming tired 2-3 weeks after you’ve made the switch is totally normal.

      That being said, though, having an earlier bedtime (30 or even 60 minutes before the usual time) can definitely take the edge off of things and help her make the transition as easily as possible.

      Have you tried that yet? Have you found it helpful?

      Chaya Shifra

      • kayla

        Thanks so much! Yes, we’ve tried that and it helps somewhat. I find at the end of the week after going with only 1 nap for a couple of days, she is more tired and needs 2 naps. So, for the weekend we usually do 2 naps, although she won’t always fall asleep on the second one.

        • Hi Kayla,

          Keep in mind that it can take a full 2-6 weeks for the dust to settle when you’re doing a nap transition. Your best bet, rather than offering 2 naps on Shabbos (and her not taking the second one), is to offer an earlier bedtime – if bedtime is usually at 7, then you do bedtime at 6:30 or even 6 for a few weeks while things even out.

          How does that sound?

          Chaya Shifra